|
Home ->
Articles -> DISH Network vs DIRECTV
Have you been shopping for a satellite television service provider lately? If so, I'm sure you have run into more questions than you anticipated. That is what happened to my mother. She has a rather large home, in which my family feels they need a television in every single room. Currently, they have cable, because really that has been the default for years. Cable is great for access to as many rooms as you want, but for the non- introductory price it can add up if you want to have a great digital signal. So, satellite will offer a better picture, but if you want to put it in more than 1 or 2 rooms, you are really paying through the nose for the additional hookups. I will attempt to help you choose a satellite provider by comparing the two largest companies. Programs and services change faster than paint dries, so hopefully this will give you a starting point, and will help you know better what to look for.
Satellite Basics
Satellite service provides television programming through a satellite that is installed on the outside of your home. In addition to this satellite dish, satellite receivers are required at the site of the television. If you are switching from cable to satellite, this will require rewiring and an installation of an ugly satellite on the outside of your home. I would suggest thinking about where you want it installed before the serviceperson comes, otherwise you are at his/her mercy. If you are a new customer this installation can be free so make sure you insist upon that. Once the satellite system is hooked up you should receive good continual service unless the weather interferes with your signal to your satellite. I live where it snows and rains, and have had my satellite reception go out about 2 times in 3 years. Satellite systems come with a great on television guide system to help finding the program you want very easy. Most satellite service comes with a pay per view option that is great for those nights that you do not want to go to the movie store. Also, satellite services can be in High Definition Television (HDTV) or Standard Definition Television (SDTV). You will pay a premium if you want an HDTV signal.
DIRECTV
My mother called up DIRECTV because she wanted to combine with her telephone bill to save money. She used DIRECTV's instant messenger service to talk with a technical support person. She was on the computer with the salesperson for a little under 1 hour in order to find out what kind of system she needed. While she was doing this she was on the phone with me in order to ask me questions. The technical support person was often wrong about what they provided. For instance, the operator was SURE that if my mother ordered one high definition receiver that she would receive high definition reception on all other televisions that were hooked up to a standard receiver. I knew this was not possible, my mother had to ask her 3 times before the operator said that she better check. Sure enough that was not possible. Therefore, make sure you know what you are getting, and don't always trust the salesperson.
DIRECTV offers the standard equipment:
(1) Standard Satellite Receiver - Standard television reception to one television.
(2) High Definition (HD) Satellite Receiver - High Definition television reception to one television.
(3) Standard Satellite Receiver with Digital Video Recorder (DVR) - Standard television reception to one television with the ability to play/pause/fast forward/rewind/record television programming.
(4) High Definition Satellite Receiver with Digital Video Recorder (DVR) - High Definition television reception to one television with the ability to play/pause/fast forward/rewind/record television programming.
DIRECTV has smartened up though, and offers to bundle your satellite service with your high speed internet service. No, you will not be receiving satellite internet service; you will be receiving DSL service from a local telephone company (and you will still have 2 bills)!
So if you wanted television reception to 4 televisions in your house, you would have to choose and pay for four of the above receivers. Make sure you take advantage of being a NEW customer, and get your equipment for free; it will be the last time they offer you that!
As for programming, you need to check with each one of the providers. Each offers a slightly different line up, and there is not one that stands out as best.
Dish Network
Dish Network is unique in that it offers a dual tuner receiver. The dual tuner offers reception for 2 different televisions, but only requires one receiver. The reception on each television is still unique, and can be running at the same time. The dual tuner could also provide the long lost, and loved picture in picture; the service that many satellite subscribers have missed. So you say big deal that you get a dual tuner with Dish Network, I can just order 2 receivers from DIRECTV. Well, here is the big deal, if you use the DVR function (Digital Video Recorder) and are using a dual tuner receiver you can record a television program, and watch it on either of the two televisions. This is an extremely convenient feature. At our house we could be watching a television program downstairs, and then decide we want to watch it upstairs while we BBQ. It can be done just like that!!!!
Dish Network offers the following equipment:
(1) Standard Satellite Receiver - Standard television reception to one television.
(2) High Definition (HD) Satellite Receiver - High Definition television reception to one television.
(3) Standard Satellite Receiver with Digital Video Recorder (DVR) - Standard television reception to one television with the ability to play/pause/fast forward/rewind/record television programming.
(4) High Definition Satellite Receiver with Digital Video Recorder (DVR) - High Definition television reception to one television with the ability to play/pause/fast forward/rewind/record television programming.
(5) Dual Tuner High Definition Satellite Receiver with Digital Video Recorder - High Definition television reception on one television, and standard definition television reception on the other television, or Picture in Picture.
(6) Dual Tuner Standard Definition Satellite Receiver with Digital Video Recorder (DVR) - Standard Television reception on 2 televisions or Picture in Picture.
|
Questions, Comments, and Answers...
|
|
Question:
I currently have DirecTV. My current setup includes one receiver,
I have a splitter so that I can watch TV in the Living room and the bed room.
In the bed room I can only watch what is playing in the living room and can not
change channels in bed room. All I want is a satellite receiver that I can
change channels in which ever room I am in. It can be the same channel on both
TVS. Is there any such receiver?
Cindy, Alabama
Answer: I recommend switching to Dish Network. DirecTV can do this
as well, but you will have to upgrade to a new receiver which costs money.
If you switch to Dish, you will get the new receiver free, plus a reduced
monthly fee for the first few months. Ask for the dual-tuner receiver!
|
Question:
If I bought a new HD DVR receiver from Dish, can I have the
option to record in SD so that the recorded shows can play on either TV?
Mike, Chicago, IL
Answer: Yes, with the Dish HD Dual tuner receiver you can record up
to two shows at the same time with the option of either recording standard or
high definition programming. You can than watch these recorded shows on either
TV. You can start watching a show on one TV, stop it, and finish watching it
on the second TV.
|
Question:
What is the effect of weather, rain, wind, etc on the
satellite receiver and overall satellite reception?
Horace, Columbia, SC
Answer: I have found that hail and very heavy rain can occasionally cause
a temporary (1 to 2 seconds) loss in satellite reception. I have never had a signal loss
of more than a few seconds in the more than the 5 years I have had the Dish Network.
|
Question:
I have standard DirecTV service and I own a couple of HD TV sets and
have them connected to the standard receivers. Will I need to get the dish on my
roof changed for HD and new receivers or can I just change the receivers for
HD?
Mickey, Houston Texas
Answer: You will most likely need to have DirecTV come out and change the satellite(s) on
your roof. This is because they probably installed a satellite that cannot except an HD signal.
|
Question:
I have DirecTV. I was wondering if I can connect more than 4 rooms
and watch separate channels in each room if I switch to Dish Network?
Jerry, Oakdale, LA
Answer: With Dish Network, you can buy 2 dual tuners (receivers) and watch
up to 4 different channels on 4 different televisions at the same time.
|
Question:
Dish Network offers an HD DVR that will connect to two TVs: One
HD and one SD. If I get the dual DVR connected to both TVs, am I limited to
watching only recorded programming on the SD TV if two shows are recording on
the HD TV or vice-versa?
Cori, Indiana
Answer: You can watch a recorded show on either TV (HD or SD) while
recording two HD shows. You cannot
watch a live TV show while recording two shows, because you are limited to watching
one of the current recording shows. To summarize, you can be watching two different
recorded TV shows while recording two TV shows at the same time.
|
Question:
I have a lake home with a Dish Network satellite. Will my
DirecTV receiver work with it?
Ted, Atlanta Georgia
Answer: No, the Dish Network and DirecTV receivers and satellites are
not compatible.
|
Question:
If I hooked up 2 satellite dishes together, would I get better
signals/reception?
Fidel, San Ramon,CA
Answer: No, you would not get any better reception. If you have a satellite
receiver, you should be getting a clear picture. I bet you have something wrong with
your television or the connection between the satellite receiver and your television.
|
Question:
How can I improve the reception to television 2 from the DISH HD Dual Tuner? Imran, Bentleyville Ohio
Answer: There are "upgraded" connectors than need to be installed between all your coaxial connectors.
I know when the DISH network service man installed my dual tuner he searched for and replaced all the old
connectors to improve quality. I would call DISH and ask them to come out and check things out.
|
Question:
I currently have standard DISH satellite connection. I am
thinking about purchasing a new 32 inch LCD TV but waiting a few months before
switching my satellite account to HD. Will I be able to use the new LCD TV
with the standard DISH connection and will I get a good picture that will fill
the new LCD TV screen format?
Etters, Pennsylvania
Answer: Yes, you will be able to use the new LCD TV with standard DISH. The LCD will "up-convert"
the picture to 720 pixels. It won't look great, but it will probably look similar (or a little worse)
to a normal standard television. I recommend upgrading to HD programming as it usually is only $10 to $20
a month, and a much better picture.
|
Question:
I have DISH Network with 4 receivers. I have two dual
receivers, one standard, and one HD receiver. I think that I can technically connect 6 televisions.
There are 4 cables coming into the house from "TEH" DP 34 switch. How can I extend
reception in to my two other televisions? My immediate sense tells me get a switch that will have 6
receiver output rather than 2. Is there a switch like that or do i have to do
it differently? Zad, California
Answer: I am sure there is a switch you can buy to get 6 televisions connected. I personally would recommend
calling the DISH and get a technician to come out to your home. I believe there is some technical details besides
just changing the switch such as cabling requirements and distance limits.
|
Question:
Does my satellite provider offer High Definition Television (HDTV) in my local stations (NBC,CBS,ABC,FOX)? Tiffany, Windsor Colorado
Answer: It depends. Dish Network and DIRECTV provide high definition television reception. The High Definition Television reception will cost you extra money per month per television, but may be worth it if they provide your local stations in HDTV. You can discover if they provide High Definition Television for your local stations by going to their website and entering in your zip code. If they do not provide your local stations in HDTV then you need to look at the stations they do provide in HDTV and make sure you will be watching them enough to make it worth it.
|
Submit a question or comment...
|
|